wiredone wroteHe didn't fix the garage door and re-rented the house?
If it was for the same or more $ than your kid was paying, I would think that that would be a small claims action right there.
Most states do not require the owner of damaged property to repair property damage they have received compensation for.
It's his property, it was damaged, he is entitled to be remuneration for the damage. He does not have to repair the damage. If the landlord foolishly decides not to repair the damage and reduce the value to his property, that's his decision.
Don't get me wrong I'm not saying I agree with the landlord's actions. Nor am I defending him. I'm just attempting to show a difference between ethical/moral behavior and legal behavior.
If I were renting the place I would document the existing damage and condition in writing and photos and make sure I don't get blamed for any preexisting damage on my way out.