paul heller wroteI bought Jacob Anderson's Bandsaw maintenance DVD but could never get it to play. He blames it on my DVD play and my computer (I tried it on both), even though my DVD player is only one month old. And... it is only his DVD that cannot play. Everything things else I buy plays nicely.
He offered to exchange it for me for VHS tapes, but I no longer have a VHS player. He did not offer to swap the DVD to try another one to see if it was simply a bad DVD. So, the whole thing was a complete waste of money.
Well, he has lots of warnings on his eBay site. Anyone who goes this route should heed those warnings and plan that they will need to later on swap for VHS tapes. That way they can only be surprised when the DVD works rather than disappointed if it does not. It is definitely a buyer beware situation.
Paul
To add credibility to your analysis, I would suggest that you try your DVD on another player that is known to be good.
I would gladly run a test if you want to send me the DVD (which of course I would return after completing the test).
Do you have any of the Shopsmith DVDs that you know play.
As a side comment: I have three DVD players in my house. Two work with all of the DVDs that have been tried in them. The third one, which happens to be where I would typically go to watch a DVD, is very intermittent when used in my area. If I take it to my wife's craft area, to play on her DVD, it works fine.
I suggested a swap but she wasn't hearing that at all. I have noticed that she has marked the DVD players so she knows which is which.