Page 2 of 2
Posted: Sun Mar 22, 2009 8:41 pm
by wlhayesmfs
I think you will find the more you are into the ER's the more you will like them. I have not intention of giving up my MKV's. The er's did have a lower blade guard you could buy but if you find one now you will probably give more for it than you did for the ER. The motor has set screws to loosen it when you move the belt and helps the motor stay with the right tension. Also make sure you loosen the motor to change speeds since the pulleys are very brittle and will break easily.
I did not have a fine caliper to use on the tubes but the ER tubes are just a hair or two wider and come in two thickness. The heavy wall you have and the later models came with a thin wall
Enjoy
Posted: Mon Mar 23, 2009 12:04 am
by JPG
kartoffelkopf wrote:Sorry, they are not.
WHAT?:rolleyes: Both are 1)52" long 2)1 3/4" OD The difference is the ID. As Ed has noted, they are thicker!!! They WILL fit a Mark V!:)
10ER in pictures, lite on the review
Posted: Mon Mar 23, 2009 12:15 am
by billmayo
wlhayesmfs wrote:I did not have a fine caliper to use on the tubes but the ER tubes are just a hair or two wider and come in two thickness. The heavy wall you have and the later models came with a thin wall
Enjoy
I have been cleaning, sanding, waxing and polishing the thicker wall 10ER tubes and using them as way tubes on the Mark V. I find even when covered in rust, the 10ER tubes are cleaning up to look like new tubes so they must have had a different finish on them. The rust does not seem to pit the 10ER tubes like I find on most of the Mark V way and bench tubes. I find all the 10ER tubes I have are 1 3/4" OD and feel twice as heavy as the Mark V tubes.
Posted: Mon Mar 23, 2009 2:05 am
by a1gutterman
billmayo wrote:I have been cleaning, sanding, waxing and polishing the thicker wall 10ER tubes and using them as way tubes on the Mark V. I find even when covered in rust, the 10ER tubes are cleaning up to look like new tubes so they must have had a different finish on them. The rust does not seem to pit the 10ER tubes like I find on most of the Mark V way and bench tubes. I find all the 10ER tubes I have are 1 3/4" OD and feel twice as heavy as the Mark V tubes.
Could they have a nickle finish do you think?
Ed, those are fantastic pictures. Thanks for sharing. Your brother should have fun! (and I bet you will be right there helping him!)
Posted: Mon Mar 23, 2009 2:15 pm
by heathicus
Looks like a great machine you have there, Ed. I just picked up my 2nd ER that I am in the midst of restoring. I've still never seen or handled a Mark V so I can't offer any notes of comparison between the two. I'm still very much a newbie to 10ER (only about 6 months into it now), but I do have a couple of notes on your pics and comments.
While there's nothing saying you can't mount the tailstock as pictured, it was designed to mount on the end of the tubes, outside of the base plate arm. You may be missing the bolt used to secure it to the base plate arm (both of my ERs are missing the original bolt). It doesn't have a big knob like the one in your photo. It has a smaller head that will not be in the way when raising the ways into drill press mode.
I seriously doubt the electrical cord is original. I can't say for sure, but I think the 10ER came with a cord going from the switch to the motor and people had to wire in their own cord to go from the power source to the switch.
The original 10E ("E" stands for "Experimental" and "ER" is for "Experimental - Revised) used a wooden table extension. I don't know for sure if the wood table was supplied by Magna or if people had to cut their own. The bracket attached to the tailstock the same way the ER bracket does. To use the rip fence on the extension table, two studs with wing nuts on one end bolted to the table. There were two holes in the rip fence that would fit over those studs and the wing nuts were used to keep it in place.
You can find a lot of great documentation on the ER here:
http://www.owwm.com/mfgIndex/detail.aspx?id=338&tab=3 There's also the yahoo group which I have learned a LOT from.
Late EDIT: I meant to mention the quill return spring and how it works. I don't know how this compares to the Mark V, but ER has a coil spring that wraps around the feed pinion shaft. One end connects to the shaft, the other end hooks on the spring housing (you can see it on the left side of the spring housing in your picture). As you advance the quill, the spring tightens. I haven't removed the spring yet on my 2nd ER, but on my first one, the inside of the spring housing was caked with sawdust and other grime. It really wasn't much trouble removing, cleaning, and reinstalling the spring.
Posted: Mon Mar 23, 2009 2:50 pm
by JPG
Ed I thought this might be of interest to you. Courtesy of heathicus. From HIS oww link.
http://www.owwm.com/pubs/338/2708.pdf
Posted: Mon Mar 23, 2009 3:11 pm
by heathicus
I printed a copy of that Owner's Guide (printing the cover on cardstock paper) and had it spiral bound. I refer to it quite often. You could print a copy and include it as part of the gift.
Another invaluable reference for me has been the original edition of
Power Tool Woodworking For Everyone, by R. J. Decristoforo. You can get a reader copy sans dustjacket for a decent price off Amazon.com.
Posted: Mon Mar 23, 2009 11:19 pm
by reible
Hi,
I've been collecting 10ER stuff for the last week. I have had plans to present my brother a notebook with things like the manuals, Ad's, and magazine articles. I got the whole collection from the yahoo 10ER group plus a few other items I've located else where. Turns out there is so much stuff that I think most of it I will burn on to a CD. The note book will be more day to day things like the manual.
I get ringed binders at Sam's Club and have a lot of my materials put in them. They have a clear plastic outer cover that lets you slip your own information on the front and spline. I just cleaned up a picture off a manual then printed it up. Below you can see how it looks.
[ATTACH]3661[/ATTACH]
I will start taking it apart for the trip tomorrow. It has a 400 mile ride ahead of it and it needs to be broken down in to parts I can box up and lift. I guess it will be in "kit" form.
It has been great fun actually having one to play with and touch. These are indeed quite the machine. It is going to be hard to say good bye to it but I know my brother is really going to love it too. I also know I have to get it out of my garage so I can get back to my hobby... which is woodworking.
Thanks of the comments and tips.
Ed
Posted: Tue Mar 24, 2009 12:38 am
by heathicus
I've discovered that restoring these old machines is a hobby unto itself! Let us know (here and on the 10ER Yahoo group) how your brother likes it!