foxtrapper wrote:It's not so much that there is a dud or two, as much as there simply are limits with an all in one machine. Routing is a fine example. The bit is going to spin slowly in a Shopsmith, making it perform poorly compared to a router in a table. It's not a dud, it works, but it's darn limited. So much so that I'd much rather get out my cheap router and cheap table and use that instead.
Well put, and rounds out a point that Dusty made well also, that (paraphrasing) perhaps ShopSmith the 5X Multi-Tool should have stayed just that. Most criticisms seem to reach the "if I had a choice" level and thus depart the baseline mission. In addition to space limitations I have another serious problem that makes SS accessories more attractive.
I'm a slob.
It occurred to me as I was feeling a grumble coming on near the end of an install of my newly acquired lathe Universal Tool Rest that No, it was really Not a cumbersome and overly time consuming changeover / setup considering the alternative. If I had a stand-alone Lathe, instead of the 4 or 5 minutes it took to switch SS modes, I pictured the agony of unstacking piles of cut-offs, tools, coffee mugs, waxing rags, (oh! That's what happened to that bowl of oatmeal last week!), drawings, miscellaneous hardware and discarded packaging, etc. from the machine, then moving whatever stuff away from it to drag it out from the corner, locating its accessories, hooking up power and the DC system, cleaning, waxing, rust-proofing (I have approximately 13.6 seconds to Boeshield any surface just uncovered before the red rot sets in), et cetera.
Goes for the router table too, and to a much lesser extent to the Band Saw and Joiner.
So sometimes using that admittedly less than ideal SS add-on is the differrence between getting it done, or not.
To the question: the Conical Disc is great. Drum sanders. Master Tenoning Jig. Maybe the best: synchronized compound angle operations using saw, disc sander and boring modes together. (I kind of think of the ability to use three different major tools with one setting, say, as an "accessory".)
Just my $0.0123, adjusted for inflation.