8iowa wrote:I recently ran across this link on the Lumberjocks forum. It deals with table saw safety for the guys who don't use their blade guards. My personal opinion is that it is oxymoric in nature, a "feel good about myself" sort of article for those who operate their table saws in this type of risky manner. Most of the comments were highly favorable, leaving me to wonder if a lot of the woodworkers "over there" never use their guards.
Are we Shopsmith guys any different? How do we feel about never using the guard on our Shopsmiths?
http://www.taunton.com/finehomebuilding/how-to/articles/avoiding-accidents-using-tablesaw.aspx
Hi 8iowa,
You asked, so here is what I think:
There is nothing wrong with your sentiments, but there are many saw operators that do not follow all safety recommendations all of the time. I am one of them. I looked at the site via your link, and I believe that all of the information there is good information. In the first paragragh, the author states quite clearly that using a saw guard is best (and I agree), but he admits to knowledge that in many cases saw operators do not use their saw guards (and who hasn't done that?). He is offering advice for saw operators that is good for everyone, but does not include using the saw guard, as he is trying to get the saw operators that do not use a saw guard, to be as safe as possible excluding the use of the saw guard, since they are not going to use it no matter what they are told or know.
Are you suggesting that because a saw operator knowingly chooses to not use a saw guard, he is not interested in other safety precautions? When I do not use my saw guard, I am taking a risk. Unquestionably. But that does not mean that I am reckless. I take the precautions that are necessary for my safety that do not include the use of the saw guard. I use the saw guard sometimes. I teach my children to do so. I also realize that there are times when using the saw guard, while not impossible, is very inconvenient. There are also times when using the saw guard IS impossible. It is a choice that I, and many other woodworkers, purposely make. To some, it is a bad decision. To others, it is a necessary decision. To even more, it is a convenient decision.
For those saw operators that never use a saw guard, that use their "contractors saw" sitting on the ground, that do not use featherboards or hold-downs, that wear shirts with loose long sleeves, that don't use eye and ear protection, that don't use a riving knife, etc., etc., I will agree with you; they are risking great bodily harm. Even so, it is their own choice, and they are/will be responsible for their own actions. The only concern that I have for those operators, is when they put others at risk. I can not condone using a saw when people, other then the operator, are in a position to be hurt.