Rigid Foam - Safer Than Wood?
Posted: Fri Nov 22, 2024 5:12 pm
I currently have a home project which requires fabbing a large number of identical rigid tiles. Any rigid material, including wood, could have been used, but "pink" foamboard was chosen for economy and ease of use. Super easy to get very clean and repeatable cuts of pink foamboard on the table saw - and at the lowest Shopsmith speed. Pink foamboard can be sawn, drilled, planed identically to wood in most cases, but at low speed and without the weight and cutting resistance of wood.
I thought back to my Shopsmith learning curve from 3 decades ago. Early on I had my share of kickbacks and near-misses, but have been very lucky to this day. I think my learning curve on the Shopsmith would have been less difficult had I started cutting on rigid foam before wood. Today, if I were introducing a beginning student to power tool use, I might start with foam - just to get the student acquainted with tool setup, tool noise, hand-eye coordination while feeding, and kickback hazard - while cutting a far less resistant, heavy and more hazardous material.
But unlike wood, rigid foam has no grain, and this detracts from realism. Also, the "sawdust" generated by cutting rigid foam is really a nuisance - the dust "static clings" strongly to all surfaces, worse than real sawdust.
We note that in the modern industrial CNC machine shop, rigid foam is first cut to test and debug toolpath and other programming problems before actual metal is cut. By using foam, the CNC machine itself is also spared from much damage as would occur in a metal-to-metal collision during a program run. There are a variety of rigid foam types available to the CNC shop for such use. Maybe a foam specifically made for apprentice woodworker education, which simulates grain and other wood-like properties, could provide a safer (and less intimidating) introduction to power tool woodworking.
I thought back to my Shopsmith learning curve from 3 decades ago. Early on I had my share of kickbacks and near-misses, but have been very lucky to this day. I think my learning curve on the Shopsmith would have been less difficult had I started cutting on rigid foam before wood. Today, if I were introducing a beginning student to power tool use, I might start with foam - just to get the student acquainted with tool setup, tool noise, hand-eye coordination while feeding, and kickback hazard - while cutting a far less resistant, heavy and more hazardous material.
But unlike wood, rigid foam has no grain, and this detracts from realism. Also, the "sawdust" generated by cutting rigid foam is really a nuisance - the dust "static clings" strongly to all surfaces, worse than real sawdust.
We note that in the modern industrial CNC machine shop, rigid foam is first cut to test and debug toolpath and other programming problems before actual metal is cut. By using foam, the CNC machine itself is also spared from much damage as would occur in a metal-to-metal collision during a program run. There are a variety of rigid foam types available to the CNC shop for such use. Maybe a foam specifically made for apprentice woodworker education, which simulates grain and other wood-like properties, could provide a safer (and less intimidating) introduction to power tool woodworking.