Page 1 of 1

Gilmer or Poly V ? second opinion?

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 10:10 am
by bob84
I just purchased my second Goldie that was born in 1961 with a the Mark V shaper kit and the Shopsmith safety package.

The previous owner stated that the original 3/4 HP motor died during the 1980's and was replaced with a new Shopsmith factory replacement Emerson electric brand 1 1/8 HP motor. The Gilmer belt and drive belt appear new and all bearings seem smooth. The headstock changes speeds smoothly with little vibration.

I was thinking of setting this machine up right now, as a stationary drill press / shaper system. It could use new paint, but is the Gilmer system good for a stationary drill press / shaper? Or should I do a complete makeover to the Poly V system with the double bearing quill, and new paint, etc. ?

Any suggestions and opinions are welcomed.

Incidentally my other Goldie is the Poly V system that was born in 1963 that I just did a complete headstock makeover of belts and all bearings. Both the Mark V Goldies will beautifully augment my Goldie Sawsmith RAS born in 1961.

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 12:26 pm
by beeg
Well to change that over to a poly-v system, I think I remember that the cost is about $500.00 for parts. I'd think it's not worth it to me.

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 2:27 pm
by tkhudson
I just finished my 1954 Greenie...took OEM belt off, I had ordered a new one... there wasnt enough difference to replace it... cant argue with 56 years of service.

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 2:59 pm
by thainglo
beeg wrote:Well to change that over to a poly-v system, I think I remember that the cost is about $500.00 for parts. I'd think it's not worth it to me.
I agree 100%. With proper maintenance, that old Goldie will run for another 50 years on its Gilmer drive.

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 11:55 pm
by JPG
IMHO, the time to 'replace' the gilmer parts is when they fail, AND you cannot find a replacement.

Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 8:51 am
by 8iowa
I would at least get her painted. You'll feel better every time you walk into the shop.

I've seen so many great restorations here that I'm beginning to get interested.

Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 9:55 am
by robinson46176
8iowa wrote:I would at least get her painted. You'll feel better every time you walk into the shop.

I've seen so many great restorations here that I'm beginning to get interested.


I agree completely...
I really notice the difference having a few restored and a batch not done yet even though they are not in bad shape at all. I find that I just automatically migrate to the restored units first.
I'll ramble on more about this later but I'll move it over to the thread where i was talking about my new shop rather than hijack this thread.
-
I would not worry at all about the Gilmer drive as long as you can get the belts. They are quite tough.